PetePierson wrote: ↑Thu Feb 06, 2025 4:28 pm
Do what you will with this info but there's no way that this is just a "conservative" problem.
"Since its creation in 1979, the Department of Education has sent well more than $1 trillion to schools with the express purpose of closing the gaps between the highest and lowest performers. Today, those gaps are as wide as they have ever been, and by many measures, even wider."
That's an issue with how it's being run, not with the department's existence itself. In America we're averse to penalizing people harshly unless there is tangible material or physical harm done.
I'd argue that an incompetent, greedy, or otherwise shitty superintendent, principal, or other administrator or faculty member does more tangible harm than the majority of mass murderers as they mentally stunt the growth of hundreds if not thousands of children. And that's without mentioning the mental health damage that is done by our education system.
We need to stop being afraid of holding people accountable for actions that aren't related to theft or bodily harm.
I am not neuro-typical. Aside from being trans, which probably contributed to some of my childhood issues though I was unaware at the time, I also have ADHD, and while I was never diagnosed my therapists and PCP strongly suspect that I'm on the very high functioning end of the Autism spectrum. School was a nightmare for me. I did have friends, and I did have some good times. But I was bullied often, at least until I kicked the shit out of someone (glad I didn't grow up in the era of zero tolerance) and my experiences with authority figures were almost exclusively negative. I was disciplined for things that largely weren't my fault (ADHD and Autism symptoms that weren't being properly addressed) and I was very, very often blamed for things I didn't do. As I got older my respect for authority eroded to what it is now, that being none, because I saw that people in positions of authority get there, not because they want to do good things with that authority but because they're scared little weasels who only feel safe if they have people to punch down on.
I have so many fucking issues because of our school system and its 'standardization' been diagnosed with C-PTSD and all that shit. See, if you don't fit in the square hole they try to force you through anyway and if they can't it's your fault for not being a square shaped peg.
If they had just worked with me and facilitated my strengths while helping me learn how to compensate for my weaknesses there's no doubt in my mind I'd be wildly successful. I coasted through school, math withstanding, with literally zero effort. I was smarter than most of my teachers, even in middle school.
This turned into a rant, but my point is that we need to completely change our perspective on how we educate our youth in this country. The Department of Education is a part of the solution but not in the form that it is now. And frankly, education should not be left to the states. It is explicitly a national interest.